solana-kit-migration（solana 套件迁移）

Solana Kit Migration Assistant

This skill helps you navigate the transition between @solana/web3.js (v1.x) and @solana/kit (formerly web3.js 2.0), providing guidance on when to use each library and how to migrate between them.

Overview

The Solana JavaScript ecosystem has two major SDK options:

Key Decision: @solana/kit is the future, but migration isn't always straightforward.

When to Use Each Library

Use @solana/kit When:

1. Starting a new project without Anchor dependencies
2. Bundle size matters - Kit is tree-shakeable (26% smaller bundles)
3. Performance is critical - ~200ms faster confirmation latency, 10x faster crypto ops
4. Using standard programs (System, Token, Associated Token)
5. Building browser applications where bundle size impacts load time
6. Type safety is important - Better TypeScript support catches errors at compile time
7. Using modern JavaScript - Native BigInt, WebCrypto, AsyncIterators

Use @solana/web3.js (v1.x) When:

1. Using Anchor - Anchor doesn't support Kit out of the box yet
2. Existing large codebase - Migration cost outweighs benefits
3. Dependencies require v1 - Check if your SDKs support Kit
4. Rapid prototyping - v1's OOP style may be more familiar
5. Documentation/examples - More community resources for v1

Use Both (Hybrid Approach) When:

1. Gradual migration - Use @solana/compat for interoperability
2. Mixed dependencies - Some libs require v1, some support Kit
3. Feature-by-feature migration - Convert hot paths first

Quick Decision Flowchart

START
  │
  ├─ New project? ─────────────────────────────────────────┐
  │     │                                                   │
  │     ├─ Using Anchor? ──► YES ──► Use @solana/web3.js   │
  │     │                                                   │
  │     └─ No Anchor? ──► Use @solana/kit                  │
  │                                                         │
  └─ Existing project? ────────────────────────────────────┤
        │                                                   │
        ├─ Performance issues? ──► Consider migration      │
        │                                                   │
        ├─ Bundle size issues? ──► Consider migration      │
        │                                                   │
        └─ Working fine? ──► Stay with current SDK         │

Instructions for Migration Analysis

When a user asks about migration, follow these steps:

Step 1: Analyze Current Codebase

Run the migration analysis script to detect:

• Which SDK version is currently used
• Anchor dependencies
• Third-party SDK dependencies
• Usage patterns that need migration

# Use the analyze-migration.sh script in scripts/
./scripts/analyze-migration.sh /path/to/project

Step 2: Check Dependencies

Look for these blocking dependencies:

• @coral-xyz/anchor or @project-serum/anchor - Wait for Anchor Kit support
• SDKs that haven't migrated (check their package.json)

Step 3: Assess Migration Complexity

Count occurrences of these patterns that need changes:

• new Connection(...) → createSolanaRpc(...)
• Keypair.fromSecretKey(...) → createKeyPairSignerFromBytes(...)
• new PublicKey(...) → address(...)
• new Transaction() → createTransactionMessage(...)
• Class-based patterns → Functional composition with pipe()

Step 4: Recommend Strategy

Based on findings, recommend:

• Full Migration: If no blockers and < 50 migration points
• Gradual Migration: If 50-200 migration points, use @solana/compat
• Wait: If Anchor-dependent or critical SDKs don't support Kit
• Hybrid: If only specific modules need Kit performance

API Migration Reference

See resources/api-mappings.md for complete mappings. Key conversions:

Connection → RPC

// v1
const connection = new Connection(url, 'confirmed');
const balance = await connection.getBalance(pubkey);

// Kit
const rpc = createSolanaRpc(url);
const { value: balance } = await rpc.getBalance(address).send();

Keypair → KeyPairSigner

// v1
const keypair = Keypair.fromSecretKey(secretKey);
console.log(keypair.publicKey.toBase58());

// Kit
const signer = await createKeyPairSignerFromBytes(secretKey);
console.log(signer.address);

Transaction Building

// v1
const tx = new Transaction().add(
  SystemProgram.transfer({
    fromPubkey: sender.publicKey,
    toPubkey: recipient,
    lamports: amount,
  })
);
tx.recentBlockhash = blockhash;
tx.feePayer = sender.publicKey;

// Kit
const tx = pipe(
  createTransactionMessage({ version: 0 }),
  tx => setTransactionMessageFeePayer(sender.address, tx),
  tx => setTransactionMessageLifetimeUsingBlockhash(blockhash, tx),
  tx => appendTransactionMessageInstruction(
    getTransferSolInstruction({
      source: sender,
      destination: address(recipient),
      amount: lamports(BigInt(amount)),
    }),
    tx
  ),
);

Edge Cases & Gotchas

1. BigInt Conversion

Kit uses native BigInt everywhere. Watch for:

// WRONG - will fail
const amount = 1000000000;

// CORRECT
const amount = 1_000_000_000n;
// or
const amount = BigInt(1000000000);
// or use helper
const amount = lamports(1_000_000_000n);

2. Base58 Encoding Errors

Kit may require explicit encoding:

// If you see: "Encoded binary (base 58) data should be less than 128 bytes"
// Add encoding parameter:
await rpc.getAccountInfo(address, { encoding: 'base64' }).send();

3. Async Keypair Generation

Kit keypair creation is async (uses WebCrypto):

// v1 - synchronous
const keypair = Keypair.generate();

// Kit - MUST await
const keypair = await generateKeyPairSigner();

4. RPC Method Chaining

Kit RPC calls require .send():

// v1
const balance = await connection.getBalance(pubkey);

// Kit - don't forget .send()!
const { value: balance } = await rpc.getBalance(address).send();

5. PublicKey vs Address

These are different types and not interchangeable:

// Use @solana/compat for conversion
import { fromLegacyPublicKey, toLegacyPublicKey } from '@solana/compat';

const kitAddress = fromLegacyPublicKey(legacyPublicKey);
const legacyPubkey = toLegacyPublicKey(kitAddress);

6. Transaction Signing

Signing flow is different:

// v1
transaction.sign(keypair);
// or
const signed = await connection.sendTransaction(tx, [keypair]);

// Kit - use signer pattern
const signedTx = await signTransactionMessageWithSigners(txMessage);
const signature = await sendAndConfirmTransaction(signedTx);

7. Anchor Incompatibility

Anchor generates v1 types. If using Anchor:

// Keep @solana/web3.js for Anchor interactions
import { Connection, PublicKey } from '@solana/web3.js';
import { Program } from '@coral-xyz/anchor';

// Use Kit for non-Anchor parts if needed
// Bridge with @solana/compat

8. Subscription Handling

Kit uses AsyncIterators:

// v1
const subscriptionId = connection.onAccountChange(pubkey, callback);
connection.removeAccountChangeListener(subscriptionId);

// Kit - use AbortController
const abortController = new AbortController();
const notifications = await rpcSubscriptions
  .accountNotifications(address)
  .subscribe({ abortSignal: abortController.signal });

for await (const notification of notifications) {
  // handle notification
}
// To unsubscribe:
abortController.abort();

9. VersionedTransaction Migration

// v1
const versionedTx = new VersionedTransaction(messageV0);

// Kit - transactions are versioned by default
const tx = createTransactionMessage({ version: 0 });

10. Lookup Tables

Address Lookup Tables work differently:

// v1
const lookupTable = await connection.getAddressLookupTable(tableAddress);
const messageV0 = new TransactionMessage({...}).compileToV0Message([lookupTable.value]);

// Kit
// Lookup tables are handled in transaction compilation
// See resources/lookup-tables-example.md

Alternative: Consider Gill

If Kit feels too low-level, consider Gill:

• Built on Kit primitives
• Higher-level abstractions
• Simpler API for common tasks
• Full Kit compatibility

import { createSolanaClient, sendSol } from 'gill';

const client = createSolanaClient({ rpcUrl });
await sendSol(client, { from: signer, to: recipient, amount: lamports(1n) });

Guidelines

• Always check Anchor compatibility before recommending Kit migration
• Recommend @solana/compat for gradual migrations
• Bundle size benefits matter most for browser applications
• Performance benefits matter most for high-throughput backends
• Don't migrate stable, working code without clear benefits
• Test thoroughly - Kit has different error types and behaviors

Files in This Skill

solana-kit-migration/
├── SKILL.md                          # This file
├── scripts/
│   ├── analyze-migration.sh          # Codebase analysis script
│   └── detect-patterns.js            # Pattern detection utility
├── resources/
│   ├── api-mappings.md               # Complete API reference
│   ├── compatibility-matrix.md       # SDK compatibility info
│   └── package-comparison.md         # Feature comparison
├── examples/
│   ├── v1-to-kit/                    # Migration examples
│   │   ├── basic-transfer.md
│   │   ├── token-operations.md
│   │   └── subscription-handling.md
│   └── mixed-codebase/               # Hybrid approach examples
│       └── anchor-with-kit.md
└── docs/
    └── edge-cases.md                 # Detailed edge cases

Notes

• Kit was released as @solana/web3.js@2.0.0 on December 16, 2024
• It was later renamed to @solana/kit to avoid confusion
• The 1.x line is in maintenance mode but still widely used
• Migration tooling is evolving - check for updates regularly